The newly opened art exhibition known as “i am 8 bit” opened up this week at Gallery Nineteen Eight Eight in Los Angeles, to much hype and talk among gaming circles. I’ve looked over the images in the gallery section of the official web site and this collection of photos, and you know what? As a gamer, I find it insulting.
Actually, that’s really not true. I’m not deeply offended at this exhibit by any means, but I do think that this is not in any way, shape or form an exhibit that pushes the idea that games are art to any mainstream audience. Why? Because there are no video games on display at this show. Nor are there any pieces from video games. Or pieces by video game creators, or modders. No, what “i am 8 bit” is really, is a collection of pieces that look at video games (primarily the NES and earlier days, hence the name) as pop culture. To make my point abundantly clear, think of it this way: “i am 8 bit” is no more about video games than Andy Warhol’s work was about Campbell’s Soup.
I’m sure some will think that I’m just being grumpy about the whole thing, and maybe I am. But I look at the work of someone like Brody Condon, and I see someone who really understands games and art and is combining them in unique and innovative ways. His 650 polygon Carmack sculpture is more clever than two dozen paintings of Mario could ever be. Even the installations of Eddo Stern, while admittedly gimmicky, are infinitely more clever than anything in “i am 8 bit”. Stern at least gets the whole mod culture, and works that into his art.
And let’s not forget about avant-garde games that make it to market. Rez, Vib Ribbon, Katamari Damacy, FreQuency, Wipeout, Panzer Dragoon or the oft-misunderstood works of Kenji Eno, are all examples of games that push the artistic envelope. And let’s not forget about the reams and reams of beautiful concept artwork that’s created for games but never seen! Blizzard, BioWare, Square Enix…any company producing epic RPGs creates really spectacular artwork that rarely gets seen outside of those flimsy freebie art books given away in collector’s editions.
So no, “i am 8 bit” doesn’t really insult me, but at a time when Square is discovering a growing audience in this country for Uematsu’s Music (if they ever come to either Lincoln Center or Carnagie Hall, I’m dropping everything to go), it seems sad that something with so little solidarity for the video game industry would get so much press. It’s not insulting, but we deserve better.